Posted by: kathymcneely | May 30, 2012

A Sustainable Agriculture Agenda

Sustainable versus Insatiable

Contributed by Robert Gronski, the policy coordinator for the National Catholic Rural Life Conference ( Contact him at

As we advocate for a new Farm Bill, our goal is to plant the seeds of a sustainable agriculture agenda. But it is worth reminding ourselves what is meant by sustainable agriculture and even the term sustainability. It has become a ubiquitous term and used by both family farm groups and big agribusiness companies. Although such overuse might dilute the meaning of sustainability, it is clear that this is an important concept in meeting our daily needs both today and tomorrow.

It may be helpful to consider the opposite of sustainable. This might be insatiable, the sense of constantly wanting more; never feeling satisfied. An insatiable appetite is when someone cannot stop devouring. This can also be applied to society when our economic system compels wants beyond our means. Society, in a very real sense, devours the countryside and natural resources – the land, water supplies, minerals, fossil fuels – in order to meet its insatiable needs.

We well know that when given the choice, people want all kinds of food at all times of the year. The “Big Ag” industrial food system makes every effort to meet that demand. But we need to ask, is this sustainable – especially if based on fossil fuels and global trade? How do we find our way back to sustainability – to come home again to a more localized system of balanced needs?

The Church might have once condoned exploitation of the earth in order to produce an abundance of food and goods, but inspired minds have shifted back to the original teachings of stewardship and care of Creation. We know among our own members there is a devotion to regain simplicity in lifestyles. Sustainability makes us seriously consider how to produce and consume according to God’s plan for us.*

*For more on this idea, see Religion and Agriculture: Sustainability in Christianity and Buddhism (2005) by Lindsay Falvey, Institute for International Development. He offers this insight: “Sustainability involves challenging our self-awareness not only in our production of food, but in our consumption and all that we do in between.”

So what would be part of a sustainable agriculture agenda? The stance of National Catholic Rural Life has long been and remains the call to expand opportunities for family farmers, especially the next generation of farmers, who will produce healthy foods, maintain vibrant rural communities and sustain the environment. We cannot say yet if this is a prophetic call, but we hold to the teachings of the Church grounded in temperance, prudence and graciousness for the gifts of creation.

Our elected officials need to hear this because we are in the middle of a “perfect storm” of economic, environmental, and health crises gripping the nation. We must call on them to take decisive actions and pass a comprehensive policy agenda to create jobs and ignite economic development, protect our natural resources, and make healthy food widely available today and for generations to come.

Here’s what we need to tell them:

Restore fiscal responsibility in farm policy. Current farm program payments are outright subsidies, uncapped and biased. Prudent reforms can restore commonsense rules to farm programs, mainly by setting limits and targeting payments to working farmers on the land.

Reward farmers for the environmental benefits they help secure. Current farm programs provide incentives for over-production. This must change to reward producers for a balance of production and conservation: in effect, sustainable agriculture.

Spur economic growth through food and farms. Local and regional agriculture is a major driver in the farm economy. It is crucial to develop policies that create economic opportunities through local and regional markets. This means a new system that expands access to healthy food for consumers, including underserved communities.

Invest in America’s future farmers and ranchers. Agriculture is a vibrant sector of our nation’s economy, yet barriers make farming and ranching one of the hardest careers to pursue. Public policies are needed that enable farmers just starting out to access land, credit, and crop insurance, and given a helping hand to launch new farm businesses.

Agriculture is a vibrant sector of our nation’s economy. Sustainable agriculture can make it so for many more of us, once we learn to balance the goods of the earth for the good of all.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: